8 Things You & Your Clients Should Know About Supplements
Sep 10, 2023The dietary supplement industry is vast and often confusing, especially for athletes. Here's an in-depth look at what you need to understand about supplements, from FDA regulations to their actual efficacy.
1. The FDA and Dietary Supplements: Dietary supplements aren't subjected to the stringent FDA regulation you might expect. While manufacturers must register their products with the FDA, it's mainly for notification, as noted by Jeukendrup and Gleeson (2019).
Unlike pharmaceuticals, these products often bypass rigorous testing, leading to frequent misbranding and mislabeling. For assurance in product quality and safety, always watch out for "third-party testing" labels.
2. Navigating Supplement Research: While a study funded by a supplement company might appear transparent, there's a difference between transparency and quality.
When reviewing positive findings for supplements, consider factors like dose, blinding allocation to trial groups, pre-registered independent variables, and controlled diets.
3. Potential Contamination Issues: Surprisingly, an estimated 1 in 10 supplements could be tainted with banned substances, as highlighted by wetestyoutrust.com.
Moreover, the FDA's 'Health Fraud Database' and other studies suggest a higher risk of contamination with non-banned yet unsafe compounds, often unintentional and due to the production environment.
4. The Cherry-Picking Dilemma: Many supplements often cite one or two positive studies to support their benefits, even when multiple other studies show no advantage.
While some have broad consensus support, like Vitamin D and creatine, others don't stand up to closer scrutiny.
5. Ensuring Safe Consumption: Before consuming any supplement, always do a little reading about its composition and effects on trusted websites like examine.com.
Sites like labdoor.com rank the quality and safety of various supplements. Additionally, consider purchasing from trusted brands backed by nutrition professionals and refer to NSF.org or wetestyoutrust.com for third-party tested products.
6. Re-evaluating Supplement Usage: The term "supplement" implies an addition, not the main content. Just as in a business presentation, supplements should offer supplementary benefits, not act as the primary dietary source. Unfortunately, marketing often portrays them as the latter.
7. Marketing's Influence on Athletes: The sports industry is flooded with supplements, influencing even professional athletes and teams. Decision-makers, often without proper nutrition education, push athletes toward certain products. The role of sports star ambassadors and targeted sports marketing also creates a "fear of missing out" among athletes.
8. The Performance Nutrition Pyramid: Athletes should consider the universally accepted performance nutrition pyramid, which places supplements at the top, signifying their minimal potential benefits compared to other nutritional levels. This hierarchy doesn't deny the benefits of some supplements but emphasizes the often exaggerated magnitude of their positive impacts.